MIRANEST › Winning Ads

Ten winning videos, taken apart

Top 10 videos by orders, Jul 31 – Sep 28, CPO under ¥27k. Together: 131 of the account’s 250 orders on 41% of spend.

1GROUP A
NV1002-1
Explainer · 1:04
26orders
¥17.9kCPO
16.5%hook
Breakdown →
2GROUP B
F02
Reveal · 0:18
26orders
¥20.7kCPO
21.6%hook
Breakdown →
3GROUP A
V2004-3
Owner story · 0:39
24orders
¥16.4kCPO
22.2%hook
Breakdown →
4GROUP A
V2004-1
Owner story · 0:39
12orders
¥14.5kCPO
26.0%hook
Breakdown →
5GROUP A
N304-1
Problem → proof · 0:27
11orders
¥17.7kCPO
21.1%hook
Breakdown →
6GROUP A
NV1002-4
Explainer · 1:05
10orders
¥8.4kCPO
5.4%hook
Breakdown →
7GROUP A
V2006-1
Presenter · 0:24
9orders
¥24.2kCPO
14.9%hook
Breakdown →
8GROUP A
NV1034-1
They said / wrong · 0:38
5orders
¥17.4kCPO
30.3%hook
Breakdown →
9GROUP B
F03
Education · 1:03
5orders
¥19.8kCPO
16.6%hook
Breakdown →
10GROUP B
V61
Offer · 0:15
3orders
¥14.6kCPO
9.3%hook
Breakdown →
11SEP 29+
NV1023-3
Benefit list · 1:12
13orders
¥24.3kCPO
23.2%hook
Breakdown →
12SEP 29+
NV1000-1
Presenter · 0:47 · Drive: NV1001-1
7orders
¥17.2kCPO
18.6%hook
Breakdown →
13SEP 29+
V2008-1
Education · 1:07
5orders
¥20.3kCPO
27.3%hook
Breakdown →

11–13 added Nov 4: Sep 29 – Nov 3, same rule (videos by orders, CPO under ¥27k), compared against that window. The ten and the sections below stay on Jul 31 – Sep 28. Meta’s purchase tracking was broken Oct 13–20.

Two groups pooled numbers, same window

Group ANV1002-1 · V2004-3 · V2004-1 · N304-1 · NV1002-4 · V2006-1 · NV1034-1
NV1002-1V2004-3V2004-1N304-1NV1002-4V2006-1NV1034-1
Group BF02 · F03 · V61
F02F03V61
Orders9734
CPO¥16.6k¥20.1k
Hook — stop in 3s17.6%20.2%
Hold — watch through4.1%2.6%
Click rate0.87%0.90%
Page visitors who buy4.3%3.0%
Shopify sessions → bought2.1%1.5%
Orders from Reels52%32%

Group B stops people a little better. Group A keeps them watching and its visitors buy more — so A wins in the middle and the end of the video, not the hook.

What only Group A does
AB
A Pom licking the jelly stick on screenF03 only in its last 3 seconds6/71/3
Says or shows “from the inside”F03 says “from within” at 0:596/70/3
Names what didn’t work — “not fish oil”, “solution after solution”, “they said it was impossible”5/70/3
20% off and/or 90-day guarantee in the videoV61 is all offer6/71/3
Product on screen by 0:24F03 waits until 0:527/72/3

The winning template built from Group A

0–3sHookA Pom on screen + one line of text from frame 1. Proven: “Does your dog look like this?” · “My Pomeranian used to…” · “They said his fur would NEVER grow back… They were wrong” (best hook, 30%) · “What is MIRANEST?”
3–10sWhat didn’t work“It’s not fish oil. It’s not your traditional allergy chew.” · “stop wasting my money on solution after solution”
10–20sProofIdeally ONE dog, bald → full coat, labelled Before » After — V2004-3 does this and it’s the only big winner that didn’t fade
by ~0:20ProductThe stick in a hand, then a Pom licking it
—Why it works“They work from the inside” · “from the inside out”
—Daily habit“Just one MIRANEST jelly stick a day”
last 5sClose“Try MIRANEST today with 20% off and a 90-day money-back guarantee”

9:16 · captions the whole way · a new shot every ~2s · a woman’s voice, or music + caption pills · our Japan monitor Poms only. Length isn’t the pattern — winners run 24s to 65s.

Keep from Group BF02’s 3-second reveal got the cheapest reach (CPM ¥4,854, click rate 0.94%) — but its buyers came in below average (2.8%). Use it as a hook, then give it Group A’s middle and close.
AvoidThe product arriving late (F03, 0:52 → 5 orders). Making the offer the whole ad (V61 → lowest click rate, 0.58%).

What to make: the build plans now have their own tab — What to make →

All ten side by side

AdGroupTypeLengthVoiceBefore / afterProduct on screenOfferHookConv.CPOOrdersReels
NV1002-1AExplainer1:04Female VONo0:0020% off + 90-day16.5%4.6%¥17.9k2611/17
F02BReveal0:18Music onlyYes0:11None21.6%2.8%¥20.7k265/17
V2004-3AOwner story0:39Female VOYes0:1520% off22.2%4.3%¥16.4k248/14
V2004-1AOwner story0:39Female VONo labels0:15None26.0%4.6%¥14.5k125/9
N304-1AProblem → proof0:27Female VOYes0:1990-day21.1%3.7%¥17.7k112/7
NV1002-4AExplainer1:05Female VONo0:0020% off + 90-day5.4%7.0%¥8.4k102/7
V2006-1APresenter0:24Female, on cameraNo0:00Sub & save 20%14.9%3.0%¥24.2k93/8
NV1034-1AThey said / wrong0:38Music onlyYes ×30:2420% off + 90-day30.3%4.2%¥17.4k53/4
F03BEducation1:03Female VOInset0:52None16.6%3.4%¥19.8k52/6
V61BOffer0:15Music onlyNo0:0020% + $10 + gift9.3%6.7%¥14.6k31/2

Green = above the account median (hook 21.3%, conversion 3.4%). Reels = traced orders from Facebook or Instagram Reels.

The pattern

01

Hook rate doesn’t pick winners

Across the ten, hook rate and CPO barely move together (rank correlation 0.02). The cheapest ad, NV1002-4, has the worst hook in the account (5.4%). The best hook, NV1034-1 (30.3%), sits mid-table.

02

What happens after the click does

Page conversion lines up with CPO almost perfectly (rank correlation -0.90). The cheapest ads are the ones whose visitors buy.

03

Two ways in

Show the change — a bald dog, then a coated one (F02, V2004-3, V2004-1, N304-1, NV1034-1): 78 orders. Explain the product — open on the stick (NV1002-1, NV1002-4, V2006-1): 45 orders.

04

Poms, and a woman’s voice or none

9 of 10 feature Pomeranians (the tenth has no dog). 7 have a voiceover — all female. The other 3 are music plus on-screen text.

05

Vertical ads live on Reels

The nine 9:16 ads got 37 of 74 traced orders from Reels (50%; all ads 34%). The one square ad, F02, got 7 of 17 from Instagram Feed.

06

Same words, new pictures, new winner

NV1002-4 is NV1002-1’s voiceover with new visuals: ¥8.4k CPO vs ¥17.9k. V2004-3 and -1 share audio too — Meta put ¥393k behind -3 and ¥174k behind -1.

Four had a strong run of about three weeks and then got pricier — NV1002-1, F02, V2004-1, V2006-1. V2004-3 and NV1002-4 kept going. Account CPO also rose in September (≈¥17k late August → ≈¥26k), but those four rose faster. Ten ads is a small sample — read these as leads, not laws.

Orders and CPO from the HK hub’s daily Meta rows, Jul 31 – Sep 28 · hook = 3-second views ÷ impressions · conversion = orders ÷ landing-page views · ties broken by lower CPO · videos only · left out for CPO over ¥27k: N164 (¥40.1k)